Mailbag 20: Durandal's Perversions

Posted May 18, 2006

This week, we'll look into if Gilbert Durandal makes nubile ZAFT soldiers wear delicious mini-skirts.

Nagi asks:
1. Given that hindsight is 20-20, and just about everyone watching Gundam SEED DESTINY was expecting all of its nonsense to actually go somewhere eventually up until about the last ten episodes or so, do you see yourself re-reviewing the series at some point, now that we all know that the random and inconsistent writing from about episode eight onward ultimately amounted to nothing in the end?

2. How exactly do Yoshiyuki Tomino's Gundam novelizations synch up with one another, continuity-wise? As I understand it, Amuro is killed off at the end of the Mobile Suit Gundam novels, and yet in Beltorchika's Children, he's alive and well (well, at the start at least). I'm assuming these novels don't really go with one another, but is there perhaps more to it?

3. Are one-off suits from the various Gundam games, like the Zeon Dolmel and Zanscare Zanspine, canon at all? I recently discovered the Zanspine while combing through MAHQ's Burke's list, and I absolutely loved what I read about it and saw of its design, so it'd be nice to know whether or not it's a legitimate piece of Gundam lore.

Chris responds:
1. Well, now we know that DESTINY is a disappointment, but I still think my criticisms are legitimate. I'm not going to waste another breath on DESTINY, except to cover the Special Editions.

2. They don't synch up at all. Indeed, in the original Gundam novelization, Amuro dies before the end. When Tomino wrote those novels, it was before the movie trilogy and long before "Zeta" meant anything in connection to Gundam. All his other novelizations are separate entities, including of course his two novelizations for Char's Counterattack - Beltorchika's Children and Hi Streamer.

3. Ah, the ever-tricky bit about continuity. As I've said before, it really depends on the individual's definition of continuity. I don't know how Sunrise would consider a unit like the Dolmel, which appeared in an arcade game, or the Zanspine that came out of G Generation. Of course, the Gundam Belphagor started out as a G Generation unit, but it ended up in the Gundam X: After the Moonlight manga, so who knows?


AmuroNT1 asks:
We've all heard legends about Tomino and his anger - particularly, I recall stories that he would physically attack fans who asked him about Gundam Wing. There are also stories that he outright hates some of his fellow directors like Go Nagai (Mazinger Z, Getter Robo) and Hideaki Anno (Evangelion). What I want to know is, where did these myths come from? Is there any kind of factual basis for them, or are they just stories that sprung up somehow from the fans' wild imaginations?

Chris responds:
From what I can verifiably discern, Tomino is a colorful character, to say the least. But I think a lot of the stories you hear are probably just that - stories. There's the story about a fan asking him about the next Gundam series, and Tomino's response was to allegedly smash the fan's model kit and say: "There's your next Gundam series!" There's stories about him hating Victory Gundam and wanting it removed from continuity. If anything, I think some of them might have a nugget of truth that has been exaggerated and twisted into something entirely different.


Idabosoldier asks:
1. What would you like to see in a Gundam series that hasn't been done before?

2. How do you think the 'super robot' genre compares to the real 'robot genre'?

Chris responds:
1.There's plenty that hasn't been done in Gundam that I'd like to see. For one, a female main character. I'd like to see a Gundam TV series in the vein of the OVAs that focuses on adult, military personnel rather than civilian teenagers. I'd like to see a setting that moves beyond Earth vs space, maybe to Mars or even farther out in the solar system.

2. Well, the super robot genre is something that will always be around, since the real robot genre was born out of it. Initially, I exclusively watched real robot shows and didn't bother with super robot shows. However, in the last few years, I've watched quite a bit of super robot shows and am watching them more frequently (especially since there's a lull in real robot shows now). A lot of fans like to argue that one is better than the other, but I don't think they're mutually exclusive and can be enjoyed together.


Dave G asks:
1. What fighter is it that Amy Bauer-Meister from The Blue Destiny is
flying? A TIN Cod or something?

2. Why the heck does ZAFT allow someone like Lunamaria Hawke wear such a skimpy outfit? I thought it was red ace standards, but after seeing Shiho Hahnenfuss' outfit (which makes a lot more sense), I can't quite figure it out. Surely Fukuda wouldn't sink that low to just have it for eye-candy. Is Durandal just some kind of pervert, or is ZAFT's policy that it is not held responsible if you are sexually abused?

3. Why are most Zanscare chicks so insane?

4. When is DESTINY actually going to be released in North America? I've seen the first episode dubbed, but that's it, so I know they've done it. Are they just waiting for the whole thing to be finished dubbing, or what?

5. Why is it that the EAF gets so pwned? At Heavens Base, for ZAFT to take it over, down all five Destroy Gundams, and for their space drop boys take that brutal hit from the Nibelung cannon, and not to mention the overwhelming numbers they have and all the stuff they were throwing out (new mechs like the Euclid and the Forbidden Vortex), they lost so badly. And even more so at their Daedalus lunar base. To take out two of their major bases, not to mention lose a full-out assault against Orb, ZAFT's forces should have been severely depleted by the time the final battle rolled about.

6. What's a birdlime launcher?

Chris responds:
1. It's never exactly made clear what Amy is piloting. It's not a pre-existing fighter like a TIN Cod, it's just a fighter. Sadly, I've never run across full lineart for it that could shed light on the question.

2. Surely Fukuda wouldn't sink that low just to have it for eye candy, you say? After all, this is the same director who took every opportunity possible to show stock footage in SEED of Murrue's breasts bouncing up and down. Heck, he even updated that stock footage in DESTINY to have her breasts bounce in her new Orb uniform. Anime military uniforms don't make much since. And in Cosmic Era, women apparently don't wear bras and can wear mini-skirts if they wish.

3. Good question. I think Tomino likes to depict a lot of less-than-stable women in his series. Just look at someone like Quincy Issa/Iiko Isami from Brain Power'd. I think it may perhaps be due to most depictions of war in popular entertainment have no women as soldiers. I think a sentiment that's expressed in Zeta Gundam is that war knows no genders. By having insane female pilots, I think Tomino is attempting to shock viewers by showing that war can affect anyone.

4. DESTINY is already available in America. The first DVD came out in March 2006, and new volumes are out every other month. However, the series won't be airing on Cartoon Network.

5. I think the massive losses by the Earth Alliance in DESTINY are the result of poor, one-sided writing. At the start of the series, ZAFT were the good guys, and I think the EA was unnecessarily made over-villainous. This is a trend that continues all the way through to their defeat in episode 45. This seemed to have no point, since in the end ZAFT became the bad guy again. In most Gundam series, the opposing sides both have sympathetic characters. Even in SEED, this was present to a more limited degree. But in DESTINY, there are absolutely zero sympathetic characters on the EA side. It's just bad writing.

6. Birdlime is actually an adhesive used to trap birds. In Gundam, it's an adhesive with a different purpose. At the beginning of Zeta Gundam episode 1, Char fires birdlime at two workers when he infiltrates the Green Noa 2 colony. The birdlime traps both workers against the wall while Char does his recon mission. Later on in the show, we see birdlime being used as a stopgap to quickly seal breaches in space colonies.


<<back to Mailbag